Writers on Writing is our regular conversation with a writer or industry professional about the writing craft, industry insights, and their own practice. This week, we spoke to JS Breukelaar about how speculative fiction allows writers to let their imagination roam and imagine different possibilities for the way the world works.
Can you break down the difference between speculative fiction and science fiction for those who are unfamiliar?
Science fiction is a category of speculative fiction, which is itself an umbrella term comprising horror, science fiction and fantasy and all the many, many sub modes. Speculative fiction comprises stories that start by asking… What if? What if one of the fundamental rules of the universe doesn’t work the way we think it does?
Who are some of your favourite speculative fiction authors, and why?
A tough question because I have so many. Ursula K. LeGuin for her humanity. Ray Bradbury for his audacity. Shirley Jackson for her perversity. Some of my favourite contemporary speculative fiction authors are right here in Australia – Kaaron Warren, Angela Slatter, Dan O’Malley, Aaron Dries, Joseph Ashley Smith, Grace Chan – all of whom are doing unique and important things in the literature of the imagination.
Internationally, Tananarive Due, Kelly Link and Jeff Ford, Paul Tremblay and Priya Sharma are just a few of the authors I love – again, for looking at what speculative fiction is meant to do – looking at an impossible or implausible situation and thinking about the human problems that arise as a consequence.
I’ve recently read Laird Barron’s new collection, Not a Speck of Light, some wonderful horror-noir stuff there. I’m loving the new season of Severence, and finally watching Station Eleven – I read the book twice, and the series is fantastic too. Kaaron Warren’s new book, The Underhistory was one of the best books I read last year, and I’m currently reading Angela Slatter’s brand new one, The Briar Book of the Dead, and it is unputdownable and lyrical and in places very funny. I’ve loved The Nice House By the Lake comics by Alvaro Martinez and James Tynion.
Genre fiction is sometimes not taken as seriously as literary fiction. What is it about spec fic, sci fi, horror, and fantasy that you find so appealing?
I agree and we need to fix this quickly! To be honest, I think that genre fiction is taken seriously by many people who are aware that all fiction is genre of one kind or another, and that the idea of “genre” as being essentially pulpier or trashier is outdated. Many writers, including myself, lean into the escapist or pulpy elements of our genre when it suits us, and many of us would love to see a return to the days when authors could earn a living from churning out pulp – many of those stories have become classics today.
I’ve read imaginative literature voraciously all my life, but not exclusively. I love speculative fiction the same way I love all fiction – for the joy of being free to let my imagination roam and to see possible new worlds and ways of being. Each mode appeals to me in different ways. Science fiction is joyfully mind-bending, horror awakens a deep emotional response, and I love the feeling of breathtaking limitlessness in fantasy, either that which takes place in secondary worlds or which makes one or two key changes in my own.
Speculative fiction speculates on what our world could become if we were to travel down a dark path. Do you believe it is an inherently political, or hopeful, genre?
Like all literature it depends on the writer and what they’re trying to do or say. I think I believe that if a writer, new or experienced, is joyful and committed to their work, the path opens up for itself in all its darkness and its light.
JS Breukelaar is the award-winning author of three novels and two collections, most recently, The Bridge and Collision: Stories, which was a Shirley Jackson and Aurealis Award finalist, and Ditmar Award winner, as well as numerous stories in acclaimed anthologies and several Years Bests. Her forth novel, Remedy is due out in 2024 from PS Publications.
Join JS Breukelaar for Writing Speculative Fiction, Saturday 16 August 2025, 10am-4pm at Writing NSW.
If you want to be the first to read great advice, prompts and inspiration from our incredible tutors, subscribe to our weekly e-newsletter Newsbite.
More from Writing NSW
Check out our full range of writing courses in Sydney, our online writing courses and our feedback programs to see how we can help you on your creative writing journey. Find out about our grants and prizes, as well as writing groups across NSW, and sign up to our weekly newsletter for writing events, opportunities and giveaways.